San Juan Islands ferry terminal troubles

May 19, 2025

Commentary: The inequities plaguing ferry terminal operations in the San Juan Islands demand bold and enlightened action.

The essays, analyses and opinions presented as Community Voices express the perspectives of their authors on topics of interest and importance to the community, and are not intended to reflect perspectives on behalf of the Salish Current.

The ferry terminals in the San Juan Islands are the poor, neglected stepchildren of the Washington State Ferries system. Unlike the other terminals in the system, they are managed by private companies serving under contracts with WSF. And the employees at these operations unfortunately bear the brunt of one-sided contractual agreements.

Such an arrangement may work for a small terminal such as that on Shaw Island, which typically loads only several dozen cars per day. But it is less applicable to Orcas and San Juan islands, where hundreds of vehicles pass through daily — including dozens of heavy trucks carrying many tons of goods and supplying necessary services that cannot otherwise be obtained on the islands. These terminals serve as our crucial economic interconnections.

In the example I know best, the Orcas Island ferry terminal operated by Russells at Orcas, Inc., employees are overworked, underpaid and suffer from low morale, which results in high turnover. Some endure 12-hour shifts, often without breaks, which can go on for extra hours when the ferries come in late. And understaffing adds to the burdens borne by those on shift, who can be as few as one or two employees.

By comparison, there are typically a dozen employees on shift at the Anacortes terminal despite handling only about three times the vehicle traffic as the Orcas terminal. And the wages and benefits paid WSF terminal employees on the mainland are much better than those for Orcas Islanders. For example, a second-year ticket seller at Anacortes earns about $10 per hour more than on Orcas Island and enjoys much better benefits, too — despite the cost of living being 10% to 20% lower there.

The root cause of this glaring disparity is a provision in the Orcas terminal operator’s contract with WSF that limits the increase in its management fee to only half the annual growth of the national consumer price index (CPI). While the national CPI has increased by 35.5% over the past dozen years, the operator’s fee has grown by only 15.3%. That obviously unfair provision leads to what can be characterized as a “financial vise” that relentlessly squeezes the operator’s profits as well as its employees’ wages and benefits.

‘Improving workplace conditions is not only a
moral obligation but also a practical solution
to stabilizing WSF services.’

Proponents of private ferry-terminal management believe that it solves staffing challenges and cuts WSF costs in remote areas. Critics meanwhile point out the human costs — inequitable treatment of workers, compromised service quality and less stability. This contrast raises a crucial question: Should economic efficiency take precedence, or does WSF have a responsibility to ensure fairness and equity across its many terminals?

The fact that recent Orcas Island operations have involved several employees past retirement age suggests that these individuals bring valuable experience to their work. But it could also imply a reliance on workers financially motivated to supplement retirement incomes, or on those no longer burdened by rental or mortgage payments.

On the other hand, younger workers are seeking workplace support, opportunities for career advancement and income growth, quality benefits, flexibility and a livable wage that can support a family. That last aim is difficult if not impossible to realize at the Orcas ferry terminal, given the existing wage and benefit structure. Thus they often leave for better jobs.

The inequities plaguing ferry terminal operations in the San Juan Islands demand bold and enlightened action. Improving workplace conditions is not only a moral obligation but also a practical solution to stabilizing WSF services. Providing fair wages and benefits, adequate staffing and better protections will enhance employee well-being and improve public trust.

As the retirement of the current Orcas Island terminal agent looms on July 1, its critical staffing problems underscores the urgency of such reforms. The transition gives WSF a rare opportunity to begin prioritizing equity and excellence over minimizing its cost of doing business — ensuring that the workforce there is respected, supported, and fully prepared for the challenges ahead.

And one good way to achieve those goals that has been suggested is for the Port of Orcas to (perhaps eventually) assume the responsibility to manage and operate the ferry terminal. It can hire the necessary management expertise, and its board of commissioners can provide the all-important oversight largely lacking in the private-operator approach.

At the very least, WSF leaders should use this transition to eliminate the contract clause that unfairly limits the agent’s fee, which should grow annually with at least the full national CPI increase — and make sure that terminal employees benefit from the change, too. 

The Orcas Island and wider San Juan islands community, represented by the county council, must also demand greater WSF transparency and accountability in managing the terminals. Will the agency rise to the occasion? Or will it let the existing inequities persist?

— By Michael Riordan

•     •     •

We welcome letters to the editor responding to or amplifying subjects addressed in Community Voices. If you wish to contribute to Community Voices, please send an email with a subject proposal to Executive Editor Mike Sato and he will respond with guidelines.

Help keep the local news flowing — support nonpartisan, fact-based, no-paywall local journalism
with a 
donation to the Salish Current — news for people, not for profit.

STRONG LOCAL PRESS.

Help us revive local journalism.

SUPPORT US