Renewable energy generation and storage facilities would be added to a list of essential public facilities — such as ferry terminals, airports and recycling or waste facilities — if an OPALCO proposal is approved.
A change in San Juan County’s comprehensive plan would ease one of the biggest barriers for new energy projects in the county: siting issues.
The proposed change comes after public pushback and permitting issues Orcas Power and Light Cooperative (OPALCO) has faced on two recent solar grid projects on San Juan and Decatur Islands. In a recent press release, the Swinomish Indian Tribal Community also strongly objected to the co-op’s tidal energy project. Some worry the change might give the co-op outsized power.
The county is likely to approve a request from OPALCO to add renewable energy generation and storage facilities to a list of essential public facilities. The special designation is reserved for projects that are difficult to site but that also provide a necessary public service, such as ferry terminals, airports and recycling or waste facilities.
Under the designation, projects that can’t meet normal development standards such as land-use designations can go through a separate permitting process. Although the process inevitably ends with the project being sited somewhere, it doesn’t allow projects “to just happen outright,” said Sophia Cassam, the San Juan County planner overseeing the comprehensive plan update.

First, applicants must submit an analysis of proposed sites, including potential impacts to critical areas and the environment. That then opens the door for a public meeting before the county council votes on whether to select one of the proposed sites. If the council denies the application, it must identify additional sites and any actions the applicant needs to take to get approval. If everything goes smoothly, the process takes about a year before the applicant can apply for permits.
“We do need to find a place at the end of the day to site the facility. We can’t just say no,” Cassam said. “So, the public comment wouldn’t necessarily put an end to the process of trying to site it … but public comment could influence which site is chosen or whether or not other sites are considered.”
Regardless of whether the county approves the change, OPALCO could still apply for the designation on a project-by-project basis.
In a blog post, the co-op stated that, “The comprehensive plan should formally recognize utility-scale solar and microgrid facilities as essential public facilities — giving them the same planning priority and permitting pathways as other crucial services needed to support our island community and local energy independence.”
Cassam said the county has only been through the essential public facility permitting process once, for a public works construction yard on Shaw Island.
The essential public facilities process is designed to facilitate discussion, but some residents are concerned it will do the opposite.
Elisabeth Robson, an activist with the grassroots organization Protect The Coast PNW focused on protecting coastal ecosystems from offshore energy development, worries giving the designation to energy projects may be opening Pandora’s Box.
“Once you have that essential public facility designation, it feels a little bit like steamrolling … It basically says the public can’t say no,” she said. “It just seems to me that we’re handing over a lot of control to our utility when it’s a member utility, and these projects have a big impact in a small county.”
Robson added that while she understands the need for the designation, she believes that it should be paired with a community value to minimize the use of essential public facilities. She pointed to dumps and a community focus on reducing and reusing as an example.

“What’s happening here, though, is that there is no cultural value to minimize electricity use; and in fact, OPALCO is pushing more electricity use on us,” she said.
Chom Greacen, an energy analyst who lives on Lopez Island, sees both sides of the argument and doesn’t have a strong opinion on the designation. She believes the conversation about energy projects, however, is starting far too late in the game.
“Where we really need to have the conversation is upstream from project siting,” she said. “We need to have a conversation collectively as a community looking at the collective need for energy and the land use limitations and the concerns that various groups might have.”
Greacen said a better alternative would be least-conflict siting, which has been used in places like the Columbia Plateau, Northern California and Slovenia. The technique involves various stakeholders, such as utility companies, tribes, environmental groups and farmers. Each group identifies areas that would harm their interests and that feedback is combined into a final map identifying the least controversial sites.
Such a map in San Juan County, Greacen said, could allow the community to see whether there are enough noncontroversial sites for renewable projects.
“If that’s enough, then problem solved, right? We can just focus on those, and we don’t even have to designate anything as essential public facilities,” Greacen said, adding that the process would still be helpful even if the county moves forward with the designation for renewable energy projects.
The planning commission has included designating renewable energy facilities as essential public facilities in its recommendations to the county council regarding the comprehensive plan. The county plans to adopt a new comprehensive plan by the end of the year.
— By Sydnee Chapman

Also read in Salish Current:
• “Solar expansion for Decatur draws opposition,” Aug. 21, 2025
• “OPALCO moving closer to tidal power,” April 17, 2025
• “Commentary: Offshore energy industry targeting Pacific Coast, Salish Sea,” Sept. 9, 2024
• “Pasture or power? Solar talk on San Juan Island,” April 8, 2024