As officials move forward with upgrades to the Post Point incinerators while searching for a long-term replacement, environmentalists push for a faster transition
Bellingham is moving forward with the Comprehensive Sewer Plan at the Post Point Wastewater Treatment Plant, which focuses on the upgrade of the incinerators at the facility while also searching for an alternative to build in the near future that meets Bellingham’s wastewater needs.
City officials and environmental advocates in Bellingham agree that incineration for wastewater treatment at Post Point must end. However, they disagree over how quickly that transition can happen and whether emerging technologies are ready today.
“At Public Works, we feel it’s important that we move away from incineration,” Public Works Director Joel Pfundt said. “The disagreement with the community is not a question about if, it’s about when.”
The city’s plan
As part of the plan update, the city wants to have discussions with the community about its values and interests in how the city handles its solids in the future, according to Pfundt. No dates for these meetings have been set.
At a recent city council meeting, Bellingham Mayor Kim Lund agreed that the city must find an alternative, believing that promising technologies are on the horizon for wastewater treatment. But to her, those emerging technologies may or may not be the solution.
“There is a vast difference between promising and proven,” Lund said at the June 15 council meeting.
One solution that environmental advocates have been pushing the city to consider is to stop incineration immediately and temporarily use landfills while pursuing a plan for an alternative technology. Lund believes that a two- or three-year temporary landfill is not enough time to find a solution. She and the city think that it may be at least 10 years before the future of solids handling is in in place and functioning.
According to Pfundt, the emissions project will move forward as is because of commitments to regulators and because it is the right thing for the technology the city has. For the upgrade to commence, Post Point will operate as usual, treating about 12 million gallons of wastewater each day while upgrades are being made.
Pfundt referred to the operation as “changing the tires as we are driving the car.”
Environmental advocacy
Kirsten McDade, North Sound Waterkeeper at Bellingham nonprofit RE Sources, continues to speak against the city’s plan and urges for a solution to be found sooner.
“The incinerators will always emit toxins even if we meet the most stringent air quality and water quality regulations out there,” McDade said. “The sooner we can implement these newer technologies, the better. We think that even 10 years is too long for these incinerators to keep running.”
On April 27, RE Sources presented a petition against the incinerator upgrade to the City Council that had over 1,300 signatures from the community.
Between finalizing and choosing a plan, replacing the current technology and sourcing the proper permits, McDade believes the Post Point incinerators may continue operating until 2040 or later, at which point the chosen technology upgrade might already be out of date.
“Prolonging the process is delaying any progress,” McDade said. “There’s always going to be better technology in the future, but we think that there is viable technology available to us now and we think that they should work with that because it’s better than the current incinerators, better for the environment, better for our community health.”
Gasification
One emerging technology in the world of wastewater treatment is gasification.
Gasification is a thermal process in which sewage sludge goes through a high-temperature, low-oxygen environment. Due to the lack of oxygen, sludge doesn’t turn to ash; instead, it breaks apart chemically, producing a combustible gas called syngas.
In Bethel, Pennsylvania, there is a gasification facility built by Earthcare Solutions. Members from RE Sources toured the facility last year, and members from Bellingham Public Works recently went.
At the meeting, the city presented concerns about how the facility in Bethel would translate to Post Point including:
- Odor management
- Air quality controls
- Feed consistency
- Material handling
- Permitting pathways
- Regulatory fit
According to Michael Ollinger, public works deputy director, the gasifiers show extensive promise but aren’t there yet.
“It’s not at that stage where we can take that process and put it in Fairhaven and operate it there because all of those other elements need to be functioning optimally with a site that’s next to an urban area, next to residential, next to the Salish Sea,” Pfundt said.
Sean Sweeney, executive vice president at Earthcare Solutions, believes that a gasifier in Bellingham would be very viable.
“We would probably be looking at a regional system to capture efficiencies of scale, maximizing a facility benefit while making it a revenue generator versus a cost center,” Sweeney wrote in an email.
According to McDade, RE Sources has just begun researching what a regional gasifier in Whatcom County may look like. She said that this gasifier could serve Bellingham if the city chose to pay into it, process other wastewater treatment plants in the area and process other organic waste such as cow manure, crop residue and forest slash.
While the gasification plant in Bethel mostly treats digested sludge, since it is more common, staff have successfully processed undigested sludge without any issues. According to Sweeney, undigested sludge is actually the preferred input.
“It typically dewaters better, so it comes to us with a total solids concentration that is slightly higher, less water to evaporate during drying, and therefore the energy balance within this material is better than digested sludge,” Sweeney wrote in an email.
Dewatering is a process where excess water is removed from sludge. The more sludge dewaters, the less volume and weight it has, which helps to reduce costs.
Some challenges the facility in Bethel has had to face, according to Sweeney, are transitioning to new feedstocks, material fed into a gasifier and ensuring that the materials and equipment selected have long-term reliability.
Next steps
“We’ll be picking the future technology that we’ll be committed to for multiple generations as we move forward,” Lund said.
Multiple projects, including the emissions project, will occur at Post Point in the near future as the facility continues to operate. According to Pfundt, the city will be moving forward with the comprehensive sewer plan and will have a consultant brought on board for the three-year process. Over the next few months, the city expects that process to begin.
RE Sources is looking into a regional gasifier for the region, but is continuing to follow along with the city’s upgrade and alternative plans for the future.
“We still think it’s a huge mistake and will continue to present our case, continue to provide them data and information that illustrates that until it’s too late,” McDade said.
—By Margaret Baumgartner